D23 Ultimatum: What Disney Actually Needs to Announce to Fight Back Against Epic Universe
The earnings call was confident, but the pressure is on. Here’s a breakdown of the projects Disney needs to greenlight at its D23 fan event to counter Universal's massive momentum.
In the wake of Disney's Q3 earnings call, the corporate message was one of calm and confident resiliency. But in the theme park fan community, and undoubtedly in the boardrooms of Burbank, the feeling is something else entirely: the quiet, mounting pressure of an ultimatum. Universal's Epic Universe is a runaway success, and its momentum is undeniable. Now, Disney's upcoming D23 fan event is no longer a simple celebration; it has become a strategic necessity, the moment where the company must deliver a powerful and convincing answer to the new universe down the street.
The era of vague promises and "blue sky" concept art is over. The confident talk on the earnings call was a necessary performance for Wall Street, but the audience at D23 will require something far more tangible. They will require a clear, ambitious, and fully-funded vision for the future of Walt Disney World. After years of incremental changes and projects that felt more like overdue maintenance than bold innovation, Disney must now prove it can still think on an epic scale. The pressure is on, and here is a breakdown of what the company actually needs to announce to fight back.
The first and most critical test will be the fate of the long-teased "Beyond Big Thunder Mountain" expansion at the Magic Kingdom. For years, this project has been presented as a dreamy, far-off possibility, a canvas for potential lands themed to Coco, Encanto, or the Disney Villains. In a pre-Epic Universe world, the simple announcement of a Villains-themed land would have been enough to send the fan base into a frenzy. That is no longer the case. A land filled with character meet-and-greets, a small flat ride, and a themed restaurant will not suffice as an answer to the likes of Super Nintendo World or Dark Universe.
The D23 ultimatum for Magic Kingdom is this: the expansion must contain a groundbreaking, E-ticket headliner attraction. A Villains land needs a massive, technologically advanced dark ride that can stand toe-to-toe with Monsters Unchained. It needs to be an attraction that generates its own gravitational pull, a ride so ambitious it becomes a new global destination in its own right. Simply adding more capacity is not enough; Disney must add a new masterpiece to its crown jewel, and they need to show the concept art, the ride vehicle, and the opening timeline at D23.
The second major question looms over Animal Kingdom and the future of the now-extinct DinoLand U.S.A. The announced replacement, a land themed to the "Tropical Americas" with potential attractions based on Encanto and Indiana Jones, is a fantastic concept on paper. But again, the details will determine its effectiveness as a competitive countermove. Re-theming the existing DINOSAUR attraction into an Indiana Jones adventure is a smart, efficient move, but it is not a game-changer. An Encanto-themed "casita" walkthrough is charming, but it is not a headliner.
The ultimatum for Animal Kingdom is a clear commitment to a major new ride system. Will the Tropical Americas land have an E-ticket attraction powerful enough to compete with the likes of Hiccup's Wing Gliders or Mine-Cart Madness? An Encanto attraction, for example, could be a stunning boat ride, but to truly compete, it would need to be on the scale of Shanghai Disneyland's "Pirates of the Caribbean: Battle for the Sunken Treasure." Disney needs to announce not just the theme, but the scale of the main attraction for this land. It cannot be another atmospheric area with only a re-skinned existing ride to anchor it.
This leads to the final, and most important, point. For years, fans have dreamed of a "fifth gate" at Walt Disney World. While executives have rightly dismissed this possibility, the D23 announcements for the existing four parks must, when taken as a whole, feel like a "fifth gate's worth" of new experiences. This is the ghost that now haunts Disney's strategy. A new coaster here, a re-themed ride there, and a few new shows will feel like an inadequate and piecemeal response to a brand-new, fully immersive park.
The ultimate ultimatum for Disney at D23 is to present a unified, multi-year vision of massive, interconnected projects that will touch every corner of the resort. They need to announce a slate of attractions so ambitious that it silences any doubt about their commitment to remaining the unrivaled leader in the theme park world. They don't need to build a fifth park, but they need to announce a plan that generates a fifth park's worth of excitement. The earnings call was about reassuring investors. D23 must be about inspiring a generation of fans and reminding their competitors who is still king of the kingdom.
The next chapter of the theme park wars will be written at D23. If you enjoyed this analysis, join our community of passionate insiders by subscribing for free. You'll get breaking news from the event and more in-depth articles delivered straight to your inbox. Subscribe now and be the first to know what comes next.